American Investors Pull Back: What FINRA’s Crypto Momentum Study Really Reveals

Is the crypto love affair cooling off? A new regulatory snapshot suggests American investors are tapping the brakes.

The Sentiment Shift

Forget the hype cycles and moon-shot predictions. Fresh analysis points to a measurable dip in retail engagement. The numbers don't lie—participation rates are down, trading volumes have softened, and the speculative frenzy that once defined the market has given way to a more cautious, wait-and-see approach. It's a classic case of risk appetite recalibration.

Behind the Pullback

What's driving the hesitation? Look no further than the classic culprits: regulatory uncertainty, market volatility, and that age-old investor nemesis—the fear of missing out has been eclipsed by the fear of losing it all. It's the natural pendulum swing after any asset class experiences a parabolic run-up, followed by the inevitable comedown. Some call it prudence; others call it cold feet.

The Institutional Divergence

Here's where the plot thickens. While Main Street hesitates, Wall Street's machinery grinds on. The institutional undercurrent—from Bitcoin ETFs to blockchain infrastructure bets—tells a different, more strategic story. The smart money isn't leaving; it's building. This creates a fascinating disconnect between short-term retail sentiment and long-term capital allocation, a tale as old as finance itself where the big players often win by zigging while the public zags.

So, is crypto dead to the American investor? Hardly. This isn't an obituary—it's a reality check. Every market needs a breather, a moment to consolidate and shake out the weak hands. The true believers see this not as an ending, but as the necessary groundwork for the next leg up. After all, in finance, the most bullish signals often come disguised as a headline that makes everyone else nervous. Just ask anyone who sold their Netflix stock in 2012 to buy a 'safer' bond.

In brief

• 27% of American investors still hold cryptocurrencies, but only 26% plan to buy, down from 33% in 2021
• The share of investors willing to take big risks drops from 12% to 8%, with a marked decline among those under 35

The decline in enthusiasm: a trend beyond crypto

A FINRA study reveals that only 26% of American investors still plan to buy digital assets, compared to 33% three years ago. Yet, 27% still own them.
This paradox says a lot. They are not selling, but they are no longer accelerating. The pandemic years’ fever has cooled, taking with it the enthusiastic entries that had surged in 2021.

The slowdown is visible everywhere, but it especially hits newcomers. Only 8% of investors started investing recently, compared to 21% in the previous period. Young adults, once the drivers of the crypto wave, are the most affected: their participation rate falls from 32% to 26%. Some clearly jumped ship after the market’s roller coaster.

And it’s not just crypto that is retreating. All investments considered risky are losing popularity. The study reminds that 66% of people familiar with digital assets now consider them very risky. A sign of maturity or lasting concern.

More cautious investors but still attracted to risk

What intrigues is the contradiction at the heart of young Americans’ behaviors. Their risk tolerance is decreasing. Indeed, only 15% of those under 35 say they are ready to accept strong fluctuations in their portfolio, compared to 24% previously.

Yet, 62% acknowledge they will have to take risks to reach their goals. Two speeches, two realities. Because on the ground, the shown caution sometimes looks like a publicity stunt.
Young people remain the most active in aggressive strategies. Indeed, 43% trade options, 22% use margin, and nearly one third buy meme stocks.

Despite this apparent decline, crypto continues to gain ground in American society. More than 50 million adults WOULD own digital assets today.

Crypto does not disappear from their universe. It is rather part of a set of speculative bets where the desire to outperform the market remains strong, despite a more cautious facade.

Social media, influencers, and false promises: a still fragile ground

FINRA points out another impossible-to-ignore phenomenon. It is the growing influence of social media in shaping financial decisions. Among those under 35, 61% now rely on influencers to guide their investments. YouTube dominates, TikTok advances, and friends’ advice now surpasses that of professionals.

This very spontaneous mode of information fosters a climate where crypto circulates as much as a trend as a considered investment. As a result, the risk of getting caught remains high.

Nearly half of investors say they are ready to believe an offer promising a 25% guaranteed return. This is indeed a typical crypto scam scenario. Yet, 89% think they have never been targeted by fraud. Trust remains high, sometimes too much.

This vulnerability leads FINRA to emphasize a key point. Indeed, financial education becomes indispensable if we want to avoid that the next waves of crypto adoption come at the expense of the youngest and least equipped investors.

Maximize your Cointribune experience with our "Read to Earn" program! For every article you read, earn points and access exclusive rewards. Sign up now and start earning benefits.