SEC’s Crypto-Skeptic Commissioner Crenshaw Officially Exits - What’s Next for Digital Asset Regulation?

Another regulatory roadblock just cleared for crypto.

Caroline Crenshaw—the SEC commissioner who consistently voted against Bitcoin ETFs, criticized DeFi protocols, and championed what she called 'investor protection through rigorous enforcement'—has formally left her post. Her departure creates a potential 2-2 deadlock on key crypto votes until a replacement is confirmed.

The Shifting Regulatory Tide

Crenshaw's exit isn't just a personnel change; it's a symbolic shift. For years, her dissents were the official record of internal SEC resistance to digital asset innovation. She argued that most tokens were unregistered securities, that staking services should be scrutinized like investment contracts, and that exchanges needed traditional market safeguards. Now, that voice is gone from the commission's table.

Industry insiders are already speculating about the nominee. Will it be another skeptic, maintaining the status quo? Or could it be a commissioner more aligned with the pro-innovation views of colleagues like Hester Peirce? The appointment will signal the administration's long-term stance: continued enforcement or cautious embrace.

A Window of Opportunity—or Just a Pause?

Expect quieter months ahead for enforcement actions in certain gray areas. Projects previously in Crenshaw's crosshairs might find a temporary reprieve. But don't mistake a vacant chair for a change in policy. The SEC's broader agenda, driven by Chair Gensler, remains intact. The commission's lawyers aren't packing up—they're just waiting to see who fills the empty seat.

In the end, it's the same old Washington dance: one regulator leaves, another arrives, and the market spins a narrative of radical change—usually just in time for the next fundraising round. The real power never changes hands; it just gets a new nameplate on the door.

Caroline Crenshaw is moving forward 

According to the SEC, Commissioner Caroline Crenshaw devoted over a decade of her life to service, providing distinguished service to the Securities and Exchange Commission. 

According to an official release from the SEC, over those years Crenshaw served, she was a steadfast advocate for the agency’s mission – demonstrating clarity of purpose and generosity of spirit even in the face of hostility from industry leaders who thought she was not bullish enough on crypto. 

Commissioner Crenshaw was said to have listened carefully, engaged substantively, and approached every day with the sole purpose of protecting investor interests and strengthening markets.

“We join our colleagues across the agency in thanking Commissioner Crenshaw for her service and in wishing her every success in the chapters ahead,” the official release read. “We know that she will continue to have a profound and positive influence wherever her dedication leads her next, and we thank her once again for her exemplary service.” 

With her exit, the SEC is now led by a 3-0 Republican majority, two of whom were nominated by President Donald Trump. At this time, the President has not announced plans to bring in a replacement that can restore the commission’s bipartisan balance. 

As such, the agency’s future stance on digital assets remains uncertain, especially as it faces increasing pressure from lawmakers and industry stakeholders who want more clarity in regulations.

Crenshaw is yet to publicly disclose her plans after leaving the SEC. However, there is little doubt her influence on crypto policy will be felt long after her departure.

Crenshaw exits amid broader shift among US regulators 

Caroline Crenshaw’s exit from the SEC did not come as a surprise, and for many in the crypto industry, it could not have come early enough. Still, her exit is happening amid a reshuffling of America’s financial regulators that started with the inauguration of Trump, who has brought in people he believes can do the job of making America the “crypto capital of the world.” 

As earlier stated, with Crenshaw gone, the SEC is operating with fewer members and two vacant spaces remaining unfilled, despite all the time that has passed. 

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), which also oversees digital assets, is not faring better. It is also understaffed because its acting Chair, Caroline Pham, stepped down from the role to take up a job as Chief Legal Officer with crypto payments company MoonPay. 

Michael Selig has been confirmed as the new chair and was sworn in back in December 2025. However, he continues to run a ship with a skeleton crew as there are many seats vacant in the CFTC while nominations for new members are still pending. 

The shortage has affected the ability of these agencies to address rapid market developments effectively. However, as Cryptopolitan reported, regulators in the US and UK have started to relax scrutiny, closing cases without enforcement and indicating that their focus has shifted to more macro cases rather than minor fragments. 

According to the law, no more than three commissioners are allowed to belong to the same party, so the SEC’s current state is temporary until a Democrat is nominated to fill the vacancy. 

Sign up to Bybit and start trading with $30,050 in welcome gifts