December’s Secret: Why Experts Say It’s the Best Time to Buy a Used Car

Dealerships are clearing inventory. Buyers are holding cash. The result? A perfect storm of price cuts hitting the used car market right now.

The Year-End Fire Sale

Forget waiting for the new year. December's unique cocktail of corporate accounting pressures and consumer holiday spending creates a buyer's market that savvy shoppers can't ignore. Dealerships slash prices to hit annual targets, flooding the market with deals that evaporate in January.

Timing the Bottom

The strategy isn't about finding a specific car—it's about capitalizing on systemic urgency. Sellers need to move metal before the calendar flips, creating negotiation leverage that bypasses typical markups. It's a seasonal arbitrage play in a depreciating asset class.

While traditional finance obsesses over quarterly reports, the real alpha often comes from spotting these cyclical inefficiencies in physical markets—a refreshing contrast to spreadsheet speculation. December's window won't stay open forever. When the ball drops, so do the discounts.

Key Takeaways

• December can be a good time to buy a used car, with slower traffic and year-end sales goals often giving shoppers more room to negotiate.
• Carfax shows some used-car segments eased last month, with hybrids and EVs dropping the most, followed by SUVs and pickup trucks.
• Comparing multiple listings, reviewing a car’s history, and staying open-minded can all help you spot the best values.

Why December Can Be a Smart Time To Buy

December is often one of the better times to shop for a used car, according to Carfax. The leading provider of vehicle history information and buying guidance notes that the used-car market—where inventory varies widely and pricing is more flexible—can give buyers meaningful leverage as the year wraps up.

A major factor is year-end sales pressure. Dealerships often push their sales staff to meet annual goals in December, which can make managers more open to negotiating on used vehicles that have lingered on the lot. Carfax notes that this dynamic intensifies in the final days of the month, with New Year’s Eve standing out as one of the strongest days of the year to make a deal. As sales teams close out their books, buyers may see price adjustments or more willingness to negotiate than earlier in the season.

Carfax also says slower showroom traffic can work to a shopper’s advantage. Weekdays—especially mid-day visits—tend to be quieter, giving buyers more time to compare vehicles and more attention from sales staff. Also, in regions with cold weather or snow storms, these events can keep casual shoppers home, creating conditions where serious buyers may find more negotiating room.

Taken together, these factors make December—and especially its final stretch—a time when used-car shoppers may find more motivated dealers, more flexible pricing, and a better chance of securing the vehicle they’ve been watching.

Why This Matters to You

December can give used-car shoppers extra negotiating power thanks to slower traffic, year-end sales goals, and even winter weather that keeps other shoppers home. Knowing how these factors work together can help you time your search and spot a better deal.

What Today’s Used Car Prices Mean for Shoppers

Carfax’s latest Used Car Price Index shows that several major segments have seen prices ease heading into December, giving shoppers a bit more negotiating room than earlier in the fall. Hybrids and electric vehicles saw the steepest declines last month due to the Oct. 1 end of a federal tax credit of up to $4,000, which has softened demand for certain models. SUVs and pickup trucks also showed pice drops in November. In contrast, vans/minivans and some luxury models saw small month-over-month increases.

Despite these shifts, Carfax notes that five out of the seven vehicle segments are still priced higher than a year ago. That means shoppers shouldn’t expect broad bargains but can use recent price softening to their advantage, particularly if they are flexible on model, mileage, or trim. In the used market, where each vehicle’s condition and history are unique, even modest monthly shifts can help shape how much negotiation room a buyer has.

For shoppers already considering a December purchase, the combination of year-end incentives and recent price movement creates a more favorable backdrop than earlier in the year. Keeping an eye on updated listings, comparing similar vehicles across nearby dealers, and monitoring how long a car has been on the lot can help buyers identify where prices are loosening—and where there may be room to ask for more.

Related Stories

How To Shop Smart if You’re Buying Before Year-End

If you’re thinking of buying in December, it helps to start by comparing several listings. Carfax notes that used vehicles can differ widely in mileage, condition, and features—even within the same model year—so looking at a range of options can help you understand what’s typical and identify cars that may have been on the lot for a while.

The guidance also suggests shopping on weekdays, when dealerships are quieter and sales staff may have more time to review options or discuss pricing. Visiting later in the day can have a similar effect. Paired with December’s usual year-end incentives and the recent price shifts reflected in the Used Car Index, these quieter moments can give you more room to evaluate and negotiate.

Before buyers MOVE forward, Carfax emphasizes reviewing a vehicle’s history report, which can reveal accidents, maintenance records, and ownership details that affect value. The company also recommends taking a test drive and having a mechanic inspect the vehicle if you want added reassurance, since two cars that appear similar on the lot may have very different histories.

Flexibility helps as well. If your first-choice model hasn’t seen as much price decline as others, widening your search to similar vehicles or trims may open up better opportunities. Staying open-minded can make it easier to find a deal.

Can’t Buy Until 2026?

If you’re not ready to make a purchase this year, Carfax notes that major holiday weekends, the end of any month, and the winter season in general are times when dealers are generally more flexible on price.