GameStop CEO’s $3.5B Performance Payday: A Corporate Bonus or a Market Signal?

Another day, another nine-figure executive compensation package that would make a sultan blush. GameStop's board just dangled a performance-based carrot worth a staggering $3.5 billion in front of its CEO. Let's unpack what this means beyond the eye-watering number.

The Anatomy of a Mega-Grant

Forget stock options—this is equity on steroids. The entire package is tethered to aggressive, multi-year performance hurdles. Hit the targets, and the payout unlocks. Miss them, and it's just a line in a regulatory filing. It's a high-stakes bet on a radical corporate turnaround, placing immense pressure on the C-suite to deliver shareholder value that, frankly, has been elusive.

Wall Street's Performance Theater

These schemes are designed to align executive interests with shareholders. The theory is sound: no performance, no payday. But the scale here invites scrutiny. It raises the perennial question—is this truly incentivizing long-term growth, or just rewarding short-term stock price manipulation? After all, moving a needle is easier when you control the dials. A cynic might note it's a fantastic way to transfer wealth from future shareholder dilution directly into one person's portfolio, all under the banner of 'incentivization.'

The Ripple Effect Beyond Retail

While this is a corporate governance story, its scale sends shockwaves. It normalizes financial figures that are abstract to most but concrete to the markets. In an era where digital asset projects tout transparent, code-governed reward systems, this kind of traditional, boardroom-bestowed bounty feels like a relic—opaque, centralized, and subject to debate rather than algorithm.

A $3.5 billion promise is either a masterstroke of motivation or a monument to misaligned priorities. Only the market's verdict—and the company's actual performance—will tell. In the meantime, it's a potent reminder that in traditional finance, the house always sets the rules, and the biggest bonuses are still written on paper, not in a smart contract.

Cohen’s compensation is tied to GameStop’s long-term performance

According to a press release, Mr. Cohen will not receive any guaranteed compensation, including salaries and cash bonuses. His compensation is contingent upon the company’s performance and the success of its operations. The press release detailed that the incentive ensures Cohen’s directives align with the company’s overall objective of creating “long-term value for GameStop’s stockholders.”

Cohen’s award includes stock options to purchase 171,537,327 shares of the company’s Class A common stock at a price of $20.66 per share. The award is structured in nine tranches that can only be vested if the company achieves its predetermined market cap and cumulative performance EBITDA hurdles.

The first tranche vests only if the company’s market cap rises to $20 billion. The subsequent tranches will only be vested when the company adds $10 billion to its market cap until the goal of $100 billion is achieved.

Cohen must also ensure the gaming company meets its profit targets. The first tranche requires a cumulative performance EBITDA of $2.0 billion, while subsequent targets increase for each following tranche up to a cumulative amount of $10 billion.

Ryan Cohen joined GameStop in January 2021 when the company had a market cap of $1.3 billion. According to the publication, the CEO managed to lift the company’s current market cap to $9.3 billion, representing a 615% return to shareholders.

Cohen also oversaw a decrease in total selling, general, and administrative (SG&A) expenses to $950.8 million for the most recent trailing four fiscal quarters, down from $1.7 billion in fiscal year 2021. The figures represent a 44.4% reduction in expenses.

Cohen’s leadership turns GameStop profitable

In 2021, GameStop realized a net loss of $381.3 million. However, Cohen’s leadership has transformed the company into a net income of $421.8 million for the most recent trailing four fiscal quarters.

Cohen and the GameStop board reached a consensus on January 6. However, the proposal will now be presented to the company’s shareholders, who will need to approve it before its implementation. GameStop is expected to hold a special meeting in March or April this year to vote on the proposal.

Data from Google Finance shows that GameStop is up 4.15% today, following a 5% surge in the premarket, and is trading at $20.66 per share at the time of this publication. The company’s stock price is still down 7.77% in the last month, but has managed to achieve a 6.27% increase YTD.

The news comes after the company’s stock fell in mid-December following a drop in the value of its Bitcoin holdings. Cryptopolitan reported that the company lost $9.2 million from Bitcoin’s correction at the time, causing its stock to fall by 5%.

According to data from bitcoin Treasuries, GameStop claims the 23rd position among public companies with the largest Bitcoin holdings. The data shows that the gaming retailer holds 4,710 Bitcoin in its books, valued at $431.91 million at current BTC prices.

If you're reading this, you’re already ahead. Stay there with our newsletter.